In response to Nicole’s post Sweet Victories I mentioned a Kokanee TV ad that’s currently running. In it, a stereotypically creepy (yellow-tinged aviator glasses, beer belly, large mustache) “glacier ranger” auditions three well-endowed women in matching skin-tight silver ski suits (whoops, alliteration) for the job of “protecting the glacier.” They ski, make sexy faces, ride bikes, and in the last scene, take off their ski suits to reveal matching silver string bikinis.
[Sidebar: I suppose this commercial also ties into our discussion of raunch culture, and female collusion in the objectification of women, since the women in the commercial behave as if the ranger’s leers turn them on, and as if they get pleasure from pleasuring him. (Yick!)]
This commerical is patently appalling - in fact, it’s so appalling that it doesn’t seem like there’s any point in even mentioning it. It didn’t occur to me to blog about it until Nicole mentioned the Ms. Moosehead campaign. Ads like the Kokanee one are disturbing examples of the anti-feminist backlash, or the cyclical amnesia of feminism - i.e. ads have actually gotten more sexist, despite the fact that we’re supposedly living in progressive times. The problem with such shameless sexism is that it’s so awful that there really isn’t anything to say about it. And the scope of the ad’s gross-a-tating-ness is so overwhelming, it’s disempowering. Also it seems like our feminist forerunners have already said all there is to say about them, so what could we possibly add?
However, is being silent about ads whose horrors speak for themselves really the right tactic? What can we do about ads like this? Should we write in to Kokanee?



Digg
seven comments
A while back I was reading a bunch of articles on the phenomenon of post-feminism -- the (a)political stance that assumes feminism's work has already been done, women (at least here in the West) have achieved a suitable degree of liberation, equal rights abound, so why not wear a shirt that says "Stacked Hottie"? There's a strong backlash at hand against the feminism of the 70's, and lots of young women don't want to be identified with what they perceive as being a bunch of hairy-legged manhaters. In postfeminism's eyes, why not celebrate being stacked? Isn't that what feminism was all about, after all -- giving women the freedom to choose how we express ourselves? But even ignoring the total inaccuracy of the assumption that women and men are now equal (what does that even mean?), it's this backlash that allows stuff like the Kokanee commercial to run rampant.
What's inherent in things like the Kokanee ad is the presupposition that women (and men) "get the joke" - that we're hip and ironic enough not to be offended by things obviously designed to be gross-a-tating. I think the idea is that if we take the bait and get pissed off, we out ourselves as uncool and illiterate to irony. Which is exactly what has always bothered me about "scare-quotes" culture -- that it sets up an anti-PC safety net for itself that makes any kind of criticism sound like reactionary self-righteous whining, even when it's perfectly valid.
I realize I'm not offering a lot of help here on what to do; I've always been a "pick your battles" kind of person, and chosen to assume that most of pop culture is never going to represent women (or anyone) in a way that I find pleasing or accurate, so best to stick to nurturing alternatives to the mainstream and ensuring that women have other ways to make our voices heard (umm... like independent feminist magazines). But in this context it sounds like a bit of a cop-out; fighting every leering, too-dumb-for-words ad that comes your way, however, would probably result in activist burnout. What to do?
Remember a few years back when "skulling" models in bus-shelter ads was all the rage? It was a little bit of culture jamming that involved taking a Sharpie and drawing an X over the eyes and a zipper-mouth on the model's face. Now, I'm not promoting vandalism, just pointing out what an effective bit of space-reclaiming it was, done with only a $2 instrument and some dedication. Don't know how much of an effect on the cultural climate it had, but it definitely made waiting for the bus a little more pleasant.
Any more thoughts?
Posted by Anna
June 27, 2006, 3:10 PM
Hey Anna, thanks for your well-informed explanation of the rise and rise of irony! The sense that there is something desperately uncool about getting your feathers ruffled does seem to be a huge culprit in youth apathy. Apathy is one of the things that's so maddening about hipster culture. While the culture represents itself as anti-establishment and going against the grain, (e.g. with the DIY ethic, weird clothes and music, and scandalously asymmetrical haircuts) its embargo on displaying interest beyond one's own pointy-toed shoe tip stops it from actually living up to its rebel rep.
(incidentally re: Stacked Hottie t-shirts, www.realmenarenot.com has a good blog about t-shirts on June 27th)
I'm a big fan of vandalism. Personally I go to bars just to read the graffiti in the bathrooms. I live in Toronto, where many young people are particularly self-conscious about appearing political, but in the bathrooms political commentary runs rampant. The only negative thing about vandalism in our post-9/11 context is how it's been co-opted by corporate advertising (see Nike's Presto ad campaign, 2002).
I don't think that I will write into Kokanee - simply because I agree that we have to choose our battles, and I'm not sure that my comments to Kokanee would make a dent.
But I am thrilled that there are spaces where I can find other people who are as outraged as me - having our anger validated even as we out ourselves as hairy feminists is extremely empowering.
PS Which articles about post-feminism were you reading?
Posted by thea
June 30, 2006, 4:18 PM
I've been caught with my bibliography down -- I can't remember the names and authors of the postfeminism articles offhand and I'm away from home right now. But will post them when I am able to check.
Posted by Anna
July 2, 2006, 12:59 PM
What is more offensive to you? The fact that a corporation chooses to market it's product to a specific demographic using humour and beautiful scantily clad women?.. Or the fact that these women are propagating these "stereotypes" by choosing to be in the commercials?
I might consider such a commercial a tribute to the power that women have over men. That the mere sight of the feminine physique overwhelms our entire thought process (a reset button of sorts) amazes me. Perhaps it is us men that should be concerned that the marketers are hitting our mental reset button and then giving us the image of a beer as our next primary thought.
But as simple minded as I/we can be at times, I know that I love the woman I do not simply because I find her beautiful physically, but because she is engaging intellectually and she is who she wants to be.
As far as what to do about this. I would not worry about the beer commercials, as long as there is a demographic of easy to manipulate males there will be sexually stereotypical ads feeding their innate desires.
The only action required is to continue to project yourself as the self you want to be. To show others that you are happy with yourself without being bound to stereotypes and they might just catch on and follow suit.
-simple man
Posted by simon
September 14, 2006, 5:21 PM
[...] I have been hemming and hawing over a Belinda Stronach blog for a while now. On the one hand, as a Canadian, feministy website, I think we should have at least one post about her. On the other hand, I don’t really have anything to say. It’s another case of: it’s just so awful, what is there to say? (Sorry, sorry, I know it’s bad form to link to yourself…) [...]
Posted by Shameless Magazine - for girls who get it » belin
November 12, 2006, 11:03 AM
Hi, just came upon your website, while doing research,..as I'm going to a "focus" group tomorow for kokanee, and being a male I agree with what all you ladies said..I will definetly speek your's and my mind , hopefully persuade them to change their way of advertising.
If they don't stop using barelly naked and obviously fake hooters girls, I vowe to stop drinking their brand. this world needs to get their heads out of their arses,and stop making dumb commercials for us mere mortals.
Jan H.
Posted by Jan
March 15, 2007, 1:02 AM
I LOVE KOKANEE!!!!!! AND THE GIRLS
Posted by james
September 15, 2007, 10:06 PM
Leave a comment
This blog post is older than 90 days old. All comments submitted regarding this post will be automatically held for review by the editors before posting. Your comment will not appear on the site until it has been approved.