I will at some point discuss here my experiences, demons, and obstacles around being a feminist who got married. But in the interim, a related rant…
I am considering changing my last name. I am currently undecided. There are many things I like about changing my name, and many I don’t. I’ve done the Grade 4 test, and it was positive — I do in fact like my signature using his last name. But that is fluff. My list of pros and cons is much more substantial and much more confusing. At the moment, as I sit in the 3-month limbo before we get our marriage certificate and I decide officially, isolated events tip me wildly back and forth between wanting to change my name, and wanting to tattoo my ‘real’ name on my forehead so that people don’t forget.
The most recent event, and the one that has me heading to the tattoo parlour, is getting mail addressed to “Mr & Mrs [his initial] [his last name]”.
WTF people. W.T.F. I made a public commitment to be with someone, I didn’t disappear.
I’m amazed that this still happens. In part it’s attributable to a generation gap — people a couple of generations older than me think of this as a formal way of addressing a couple. There is no malice intended, and I doubt there is much thought around it at all. But I’m shocked at how many people my parents age, and even younger, think nothing of addressing post this way. And without the excuse of generational differences are the telemarketers, who are also extremely guilty of this practice: “Is Mr or Mrs [his first name] [his last name] available?”
Many women I know who have changed their last name have not felt that it impacted their sense of their identity because they identified more strongly with their first name than their last. But choosing to take your partner’s last name (in either direction) is not the same as saying ‘call me whatever’.
I have a very short catalogue of hardcore peeves in this world. But having /my name/ completely wiped away — without consulting me and as if it were no big deal? That’s going on the list.



Digg
16 comments
Catheine: You = Awesome.
"WTF people. W.T.F. I made a public commitment to be with someone, I didn’t disappear."
Again, awesome.
I always have fun with telemarketers when they make heteronormatve assumptions about me living in a house with my partner and ask for Mrs. His last name. "Nope, nobody here by that name, sorry. Bye."
I heard recently that Katie Holmes might be taking Tom Cruise's last name because he "really wants her to." Previously she wasn't into it. Much like Sarah Michelle Prinze, I find this odd, but in the interest of choice I don't judge. You are right though - becoming Mrs. His First name/His last name is even more problematic than simply swapping your last. It is a disappearing act to say the least.
Posted by Stacey May
December 13, 2007, 5:23 PM
Hate the telemarketers. Here, they call and ask for 'Mrs P____'. I live with my sister. We are both called Miss P____. Mrs P_____ is our mother, who is dead. If I'm alone here when they call, I sometimes tell them that. It makes them hang up fast.
I've been thinking of doing the name-change-thing myself when I marry in Jan/Feb. I want rid of the name I have, I know that - but I hadn't thought about the Mr & Mrs thing before. *feels ill*
Posted by Thene
December 13, 2007, 6:49 PM
Thanks Stacey May. My literally disappearing ego appreciates that.
My new favourite thing to do with telemarketers is just say I'm him when they ask for my partner. They usually keep calling until they get the person they have on their list. So I just say "yep that's me". What are they going to do? Tell me I don't sound like a man? It really throws them off their game. It's fun and effective.
Telemarketers, let's dance you and I.
Posted by Catherine
December 13, 2007, 6:53 PM
I hear you Thene. I really didn't see the Mr & Mrs complications coming. I had thought through how I felt about sharing his last name, but I hadn't thought about how I felt being referred to as 'Mr & Mrs Him'.
Loving someone isn't the same as wanting to subsume your entire public identity under theirs. I'm represented there how exactly? As the 's'?
Posted by Catherine
December 13, 2007, 7:02 PM
Something I like to do for fun is take my male friends names and call them Mr [Their Partner's First and Last Name]. This always makes us laugh because it's so absurd - as is often the case, flipping things to make a less privileged party the privileged one brings to light just how preposterous they are.
Re: telemarketers - I always try to be nice to them. I know that sounds strange, but having held many humiliating jobs - especially ones that force you to interact with people who hate you - on the road to my present great one, I gots lots of sympathy.
Posted by Thea
December 13, 2007, 8:15 PM
It's not about not being nice to them -- I'm perfectly polite. But we're currently without a way to opt out of getting spam phone calls. My phone rings all day long with spam. We pay for call display just to help us avoid picking up a dozen unwanted interruptions a day. Those interruptions are unfair to us.
My solution works well for me. I feel perfectly able to speak on my partner's behalf about a new super awesome cool hi-speed internet and cable package, the telemarketer gets to check us off their list, and I don't get called over and over and over by the same company until I really do feel like being rude/abrupt to whoever's doing the dialing.
Posted by Catherine
December 13, 2007, 8:35 PM
Keeping your last name is important, I think. Not only does it preserve your identity, when people ignore your choice it shows you, in some small way who they are and what they think of your politics (which at this point are far from a flippant trend). It's also a small point you can expect to be a big deal, like the choice to identify as femmenist. I have trouble understanding why anybody would not keep their name in this day and age. I especially can't stand that the last line of so many weddings spoken by the minister is, "I present to you Mr and miss ---". What about divorce, by the way? Would you want to be Miss HIM if he is no longer evan tied to you and how about children?(the Toronto Star had an ineresting article about this, particularly centering on kids of divorcees.) When I notice this in my family weddings, I never say anything about it. How could I? The bride has given herself not so much to her husband as to an ideology. Upon that choice rest many things it is not my place to challenge (like her right to invest herself fully in a relationship that I seldom know very much about.) Still, I'm baffled and i wish I could ask for an explanation. I think even some parents feel that way and never do. Something huge has happened to these women's heads and I feel femmenism has failed them, but even if I'm wrong there's no way to know. No proper way to ask.
Posted by Myra
December 15, 2007, 2:53 PM
"I always have fun with telemarketers when they make heteronormatve assumptions about me living in a house with my partner"
Stacey - i may be too innocent or stupid - but what is your situation?
Posted by Michelle
December 16, 2007, 4:57 AM
I hope you don't mind if I weigh in with a slightly tangential but related note regarding the choice to change your last name ...
Children. Whose last name do they get? In my case, my spouse and I are common-law and we decided that our children would take their father's last name (which now has me reflecting much more critically about this decision ... perhaps more on that another time). As a result of not having the same last name, when my son and I travel together without his father I will need to carry a notarized form stating our relationship as mother and son. A minor pain in the ass.
It also raises interesting questions regarding a child's identity vis a vis their last name. Does anyone know a couple that chose to give their children their mother's maiden name?
Posted by Christine
December 16, 2007, 4:04 PM
I think my parents were fairly progressive with the whole naming their children thing. My mother still took my dad's last name because she felt it was the normal thing to do. Past that they decided that their female offspring (me) would get my dad's last name, and male offspring (my two brothers) would get my mom's maiden name. I'm not sure why exactly they did this, but I think it's pretty cool. The only downside is that my brothers also look much more similar to each other than to me, so a lot of people assume we are half or step siblings.
Posted by IamKateness
December 18, 2007, 2:02 PM
I know this is completely Judgey Judgersons, but whenever a woman I know gets married and takes on her male partner's name, I kinda feel weird/sad about it. My mom kept her own last name, and if I ever get married (which seems unlikely at the moment), I know I'd keep mine too. It's not that I love the sound of it — but after 27 years, it's part of my identity both personally and professionally. The thought of being addressed as Mr. and Mrs. HIM gives me the creeps.
That said, I understand the desire to have a shared family name. This discussion brings to mind the opera singer Measha Brüggergosman, whose unwieldy last name is an amalgamation of her birthname (Gosman) and her partner's birthname (Brügger). As far as I recall, both of them changed their names.
Posted by melinda
December 18, 2007, 2:58 PM
I didn't know that about Measha - I always thought it was an interesting name...
My co-worker has two kids: one has her last name and the other has her partner's last name. I think that's an interesting solution but I have to say I am much more selfish - if I have babies with anyone, they're getting my last name! I know a few people who've done that and I don't know why it would cause any more problems than giving the babies the man's last name.
Posted by Thea
December 18, 2007, 3:12 PM
I hate to tell you Catherine, but I kept my last name- and was announced as such at my wedding- and I STILL get relatives (and junk mail) who send mail to Mrs. [Hisfirstname] [Hislastname] (including for a brief period of time my own mother!) I've still been reduced to an "s" on the end of Mr. Mr.'s. I've learned to politely correct for anyone of my parents generation or younger, but I let it go for older generations.
We do, however, sometimes get mail for Mr. [myfirstinitial] [mylastname] which amuses me. I know some women whose husbands get upset by that but mine just rolls his eyes at the stupidity of it all.
As for children, my last name will be a second middle name and they will have his last name as a "formal" last name, but at least they will still carry my name with them their whole lives. And honestly, I know enough women whose children have a different last name (divorce or were unmarried when they had the kids) and it really doesn't cause them problems, so I'm not all that worried about there not being one single family name.
Posted by Leah
December 18, 2007, 11:57 PM
I have to chime in here: I'm in the process of trying to get in touch with a bunch of writers and activists who were active in the 1970's, using the phone book as my main guide, and I'm having trouble tracking down many of the women - so many of them seem to have disappeared into their husbands' names. So, if in thirty years you want to be tracked down by people who are enthusiastic about work you did in your youth, don't change your name. Word to the wise.
Posted by Anna
December 19, 2007, 1:42 PM
I'm thinking of becoming a Mrs. when i marry - partly because of my conservative family and town i don't see many options - but also because I'm pretty sick of "Judgey Judgersons" treating adult women who choose to be a Mrs. as like some sort of traitor or anti-feminist. The world doesn't work in such a "magpie" way.
Posted by Michelle
December 20, 2007, 12:34 AM
I changed my name when I got married--my sister didn't. We both get "Judgy Judgersoned" about our choice on this--that is what makes me sad. Women are doubting/questioning other women's ability to make an intelligent, informed decision about what she wants to be called.
I think what you call yourself is a personal decision, and any meaning attached to this decision is also personal. For me, I don't think changing your name means you are giving up your own identity (my identity is perfectly in tact, thank you very much). And I also don't think keeping your name means you love or respect your husband any less. If other people have strong feelings about this one way or the other, then by all means, they should make the right choice for themselves if they get married. But don't go ascribing your meaning for things to my decision!
Posted by H
December 20, 2007, 12:17 PM
Leave a comment
This blog post is older than 90 days old. All comments submitted regarding this post will be automatically held for review by the editors before posting. Your comment will not appear on the site until it has been approved.