Some of you may have heard that Toronto city councilor Rob Ford recently got himself into some trouble by saying the following (moronic and offensive) thing in a speech proposing that stores be allowed to open when they wish:
“Go to Hong Kong, okay? I’ve been there. You want to see workaholics? Those Oriental people work like dogs. They work their hearts out … that’s why they’re successful in life. … I’m telling you, Oriental people, they’re slowly taking over, because there’s no excuses for them. They’re hard, hard workers.”
My sincere apologies if you just spat your drink all over your keyboard. Toronto’s Mayor David Miller rightly demanded that Ford apologize and Ford refused. Victoria Shen (Co-President of the Toronto Chapter of the Chinese Canadian National Council) wrote a brilliant open letter in response to Ford’s comments, stating, “It is not enough to deride and be outraged by racist comments. Words are empty. Sanctions are merely palliative. We challenge those who are genuinely offended by Councillor Ford’s comments to run for office at the next Municipal election. It is the only way.”
(I’m still trying to figure out the image choice that accompanies BlogTO’s reposting of Shen’s letter, but I’ll leave that alone.)
Now, Rob Ford is not exactly known for his ability to come up with the best ideas or say the most tactful things. Torontoist lets us know he had this to say about why Toronto shouldn’t fund an AIDS prevention program:
“If you are not doing needles and you are not gay, you won’t get AIDS probably. That’s bottom line.” Of course, when it was pointed out that heterosexual women are the fastest-growing group of AIDS patients, Ford postulated “How are women getting it? Maybe they are sleeping with bisexual men.”
For reals? How is this man allowed to serve the city of Toronto? I’ll tell you how. There are so many people who just don’t see what the big deal is when leaders say these kinds of things. There’s been a lot of arguing on the blogs about how objection to his most recent statement is “nitpicky” and people who think he should apologize are overreacting. There are even people in the “media” who say crap like this:
“This preoccupation with what people say and how they say it and finding offense in everything said is happening, I suspect, for the same reason that dogs lick their genitals. It’s because they can.”
Again: for reals? But no, there’s more. Apparently those of us who appropriate words for self-identification are hypocrites. Again, from the Canada Free Press:
“Most recently radical feminist women have begun using the C-word (which to me is probably one of the most offensive words in the English language) as an identity tag. I recall an article by the columnist Barbara Kay wherein she quoted a woman who had emailed her a proud proclamation that ‘women are c–s.’ Kay was appalled at the idea that women would be using that term as a self-descriptive term.”
You know what, cunts? I’m not even going to go there. What I am going to say is that the reason we have to call out and condemn public officials for what they say is because they have the very public power to indicate what kind of speech is okay. And hate speech is never okay, regardless of the intention (Ford said he meant it as a “compliment.”)
Just to give you an idea of why I think public officials need to be called on their hate-filled bullshit before everyone feels like they have an all access pass to spew vile rhetoric - Oklahoma State Rep. Sally Kern didn’t know that she was being recorded in a meeting when she launched into a speech about what she thinks of her gay and lesbian constituents. What results is a real indicator of why it’s important that public officials be held accountable for their words:
As for Rob Ford:
“I don’t know why I should (apologize),” Ford said. “People aren’t asking me to.”
Well, why don’t you go ahead and ask him to?
UPDATE: From The Toronto Sun
Councillor Rob Ford says he has apologized to as many as 20 people who objected to his comments about “Oriental people.”
Ford, who is considering running for mayor in 2010, sparked controversy at last week’s city council meeting when he made comments which included “these Oriental people work like dogs, they sleep beside their machines.”
Called on by Mayor David Miller to apologize on the floor of council, Ford chose to say sorry personally to those who were offended.
Ford said yesterday that he has apologized to “15 to 20” people who contacted him.



Digg
six comments
I heard that Ford said something on the CBC about how he wasn't going to apologise totally because lots of Asian people had told him he didn't need to apologise. Once and for all, just because some people of colour aren't offended by racist comments, that doesn't mean they're not racist!
I do think that this is a pretty fascinating example of how racism plays out in contemporary, urban North America, whereby racist comments often come in the form of phrases that are considered complimentary - and the speaker is then baffled when people get upset, because they were trynna say something nice. Generalisations of any kind are hurtful, ignorant and exhausting (and for the record I should say that I wouldn't totally class Ford's comments as benign - saying "Oriental people. They're slowly taking over" is actually more on the level of alarmist xenophobia than complimentary.)
Thanks for blogging about this SMF - I didn't have the energy to do it.
Posted by Thea
March 10, 2008, 2:07 PM
If I hated "Oriental people", I wouldn't comment on how prolific their work ethic is. In my opinion, you really gotta want to hate someone for it to be considered hate speech. I like chinese food. oh fuck me, now I'm a racist.
Posted by reighny
March 11, 2008, 12:46 AM
Um yeah I don't see how saying some group works hard is racist. Though they may only work hard because they won't eat otherwise.
Sorry, I think some people see racism everywhere, and this is just one more example. The really pathetic thing is that my previous sentence is considered "racist" by some -- again proving my point.
This is pathalogical, but I don't know how to help you see that. Over-sensitivity is not healthy, it is harmful.
Define "racism", "oppression", "offensive", "causes actual harm", "tactless", "lame". To you, these words are all the same.
As for the anti-gay comments -- that sounded she wanted to exclude people. But you appparently can't tell the difference between wanting to exclude someone and saying some group works hard!!
People scare me with this bizarre lack of comprehension.
Posted by m Andrea
March 12, 2008, 2 PM
That video is POWERFUL. I suppose I'm glad (uh, not really) that Quebec isn't the only place where elected officials make bigoted comments and don't understand why anyone would be bothered.
To those commenters above who don't see the comments as hurtful or racist - well, ANY comment that makes broad stereotypical assumptions is potentially harmful, even if it doesn't imply hatred toward the group. Even the commonly-heard "I love gay men, because they smell good, know how to party, and have top-notch fashion sense" can be hurtful because it reduces a very diverse group of people to a couple of neat adjectives. And when public figures actively promote stereotypes, especially threatening stereotypes, it's easy for those cardboard-cutout characters they've created to fuel full-out bigotry.
And, as Thea pointed out, Ford's comments most definitely imply a THREAT, not just a friendly "Way to be so productive, guys!"
Posted by Anna
March 12, 2008, 4:09 PM
If you look at Ford's previous comments that have made headlines, his comment on Orientals feels like more than just a benign "way to be, guys!" as Anna and Thea said.
Also, the term Oriental is horribly outdated. The last time I heard it used was from a comic printed in the 1930's. It has such an imperialist, "white people are the best ever" vibe to it when used.
Posted by Sarah
March 13, 2008, 7:08 AM
I, unfortunately, have the displeasure of knowing Rob Ford through business dealings. He's as dumb and closed-minded as all his previous behaviour suggests (this is just one of many 'foot-in-mouth' incidents in Ford's public career). His intent was to express alarm over Asians' success in business, something he attributes to simple hard-work. His intent was to say to those folks who look like him (you know, "real Canadians") -- "Be careful, Asians are winning at this game and unless we learn to work just as hard, they'll take over. And you don't want that to happen." That IS HIS NATURE, and that's what he wanted to say, everything else is spin.
Posted by Ed
March 19, 2008, 1:23 PM
Leave a comment
This blog post is older than 90 days old. All comments submitted regarding this post will be automatically held for review by the editors before posting. Your comment will not appear on the site until it has been approved.